Spinning reel vs Casting reel : Which do you need?
When you’re shopping for fishing equipment, one of the essential items would be the reel.
While there are many types, the two most common are the spinning reels and baitcaster ones.
However, choosing between them isn’t easy if you don’t understand the advantages and disadvantages of each.
In this article, I’ll draw a comparison between the two types to make it easier for you to make your choice.
Baitcaster Reels Overview
Baitcasters are also known as conventional reels, and they've been around for a while. Due to the more complicated operation of the reel, it’s typically used by more experienced fishermen.
This is also because they offer more control and precision.
As you cast, the spool moves, and this requires higher skills on the angler’s end to produce the right inertia power to move the spool.
Moreover, baitcasters provide you with more durability and strength. It’s more capable when it comes to withstanding heavier lines and reeling in bigger fish.
When to Use a Baitcaster?
If you fish using heavier lines and lures, nothing will accommodate them better than a baitcaster reel.
Unlike other options, it doesn’t lose any accuracy or control when things get heavier.
Moreover, when you overcome the challenge of casting the line properly, your fishing experience will feel ten times better.
- Line doesn’t twist as much
- More control over bait speed
- Accurate even with heavier lures
- Better overall control and accuracy
- A larger variety of available gear ratios
- More lightweight
- Superior line capacity
- Very durable
- Has a long learning curve
- Wears out lighter lines
- Harder to maintain
- More expensive
- Not suitable for beginners
- Jamming and bird nesting are more common
- Lines tend to dig into the pole during flexing
Spinning Reels Overview
I don’t think anyone that’s gone fishing hasn’t used a spinning reel at some point or another. It’s a great choice when it comes to catching bass, redfish, crappie, and many small to medium-sized fish.
It’s equipped with a fixed spool below the rod that depends on the weight of the bait, lure and tackle to pull out the line.
When to Use a Spinning Reel?
If you’re going to use a line less than 10 pounds, a spinning reel would be the better option for you. They’re also better when it comes to using lighter lures and lines.
This is because more flexibility to bend is required when using lighter equipment.
With baitcasters, the rod flexes and causes the line to rub against the rod blank. Repeated rubbing, then, causes the line to weaken and eventually break.
- Less tangling
- Easier to learn and improve with
- More affordable
- Longer line lifespan
- Less jamming and bird nesting
- Easy maintenance
- Considerably superior casting distance
- Can be used for various fishing styles
- No line digging
- More efficient with lighter lines and lures
- Lower line capacity
- Can’t handle bigger or stronger fish
- Line twists are more common
- Not as accurate
- Provides less control
- Hard to flip or pitch
- Limited gear ratios available
- Loses accuracy with heavier lures
Spinning vs Baitcaster Reels: Which One to Choose?
If you’re still having a hard time deciding, ask yourself a couple of questions.
What fish are you planning to catch? Baitcasters are better for bigger fish.
What lines and lures are you going to be using? Go for a spinning reel if you’ll be using lighter-weight ones.
How experienced are you? If you’re only starting out, go for a spinning reel as it would be easier to use and hone your skills.
How often are you willing to provide maintenance? Baitcasters need more frequent and careful maintenance than spinning reels do. But then again, that’s because they’re generally more durable and have superior construction.
What's your budget? If you're on a tight one, then finding an excellent baitcaster reel would be a very tough task –I’d recommend going for a spinning reel.
Baitcaster reels are more durable and suit tougher conditions. Whether it’s battling against heavier, more stubborn, or stronger fish or harsh weather conditions.
They have superior drag pressure that allows you to have longer fights.
Moreover, they’re more accurate and provide you with a good experience when you’re saltwater fishing.
On the other hand, the weight of a spinning reel doesn’t rest on the rod, so they’re easier to hold.
Spinning reels are more suitable for freshwater fishing. They also have less backlash and are easier to cast under trees and above plants in water.
So to know which of them to choose, you just have to think about the type of fishing you’ll do and the environment around you.